Source.

One technique-able counting problem type that you might come across on the SAT is what I’ll call a “possibilities” problem*. It might involve cards (but not playing cards – the SAT doesn’t like those), or pictures being lined up on a wall in different orders. Your job will be to determine the number of possible outcomes given a particular scenario. Like so:

  1. Mike is arranging seven of his various awards and commendations on a shelf in his office. If he insists that his hard-fought Class of 1999 Math Award be placed in the center, in how many different orders could he arrange the seven items?
     
    (A) 60
    (B) 72
    (C) 120
    (D) 720
    (E) 1440

The best way to tackle a possibilities problem like this is to draw a bunch of blanks like you’re about to play Hangman, and then start thinking, methodically, through the choices you have at every step along the way. I’m going to illustrate this process with slightly more thoroughness than you probably will on test day (you won’t need to make up award names, but I will because it’s hilarious):

Position
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Award
Class of 1999 Math Award
Choices
1

 

First, as I did above, you must account for any special conditions or restrictions. The Math Award must go in the middle, so there’s only one choice for Position 4.

Position
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Award
Invisible Man Award
Class of 1999 Math Award
Choices
6
1

 

Once all the restrictions are accounted for, start filling in the rest of the spaces. To fill Position 1, Mike has 6 different awards to choose from. Say, for argument’s sake, he chooses the Invisible Man Award next.

Position
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Award
Invisible Man Award
Acne League – Most Improved
Push Ups Contest – Last Place
Class of 1999 Math Award
Spin the Bottle – Luckiest Player Ever
5th Grade Science Fair – 2nd Place
Shortest Fight in School History – Loser
Choices
6
5
4
1
3
2
1

 

To fill the next spot, since he used up the Invisible Man Award, he has 5 awards left to choose from. Once he chooses the Acne League – Most Improved award for Position 2, he has 4 choices for Position 3. He continues this process until he’s filled all the positions.

To calculate the number of different arrangements Mike could have made, multiply the number of choices he had at every step:

6 × 5 × 4 × 1 × 3 × 2 × 1 = 720

When solving a possibilities problem, set up the hangman blanks, then imagine yourself actually performing the task described. First take care of special conditions or restrictions, and then take care of everything else. At every step, ask yourself “How many choices do I have?” And then ask yourself “How many choices do I have now?” And then – you guessed it – ask yourself how many choices you have again.

Stop when you run out of choices.

Possibly you’re interested in more practice?

You need to be registered and logged in to take this quiz. Log in or Register

 

*Aside from this footnote, I’m deliberately avoiding the terms “permutation,” “combination,” and “factorial” here. That’s not because I don’t know them; it’s because I’ve found that they manufacture more confusion than they alleviate on the SAT. Remember: The SAT is not a math test! If you prefer to solve the questions laid out here by cramming them into nPr and nCr notations in your calculator, be my guest, but don’t cry to me when you miss counting questions on the SAT.

Comments (23)

Sure! The basic idea is that there are 10 cards that could be pulled for when he chooses the first card, then 9 choices left for the second pull, 8 choices left for the 3rd pull, and 7 choices left for the fourth.

10*9*8*7 = 5040.

Remember, the important question to ask yourself at every choice is: “How many choices do I have?”

in question #19, in the last sentence, i thought it meant that how many card arrangement could be made out of the four chosen cards. don’t you think the last sentence is a bit ambiguous ? Also, if it is ambiguous, do such sentence structure in math come up in exam ?

Can’t you just take the factorial of 6? I remember a long time ago my Algebra teacher told me that possibility questions could be solved with factorials.

Yes, the awards problem simplifies to 6!. But that’s only because there’s only one constraint on it. It would get more complicated if, for example, 3 of the awards needed to go in the middle 3 spots, and the other awards could go anywhere. You could still reduce the solution to factorials (3!4!), but i doubt it would be any faster than just listing out the possibilities for each position as done above.

Factorials, and combinatorics in general, become more necessary when problems involve bigger numbers. On the SAT, the numbers will always remain small, so I choose not to use a chainsaw when a butter knife will do. 🙂

For number 17. I don’t understand it. Let us have ABCDE, for the five family members respectively. A and F have only 1 possibility. Then, for BCD in the middle, there are 3*2*1 possibilities. Why is the answer 12?

Alicia’s mom and dad just have to be on opposite ends. So Alicia could put her mom first and her dad last, or she could put her dad first and her mom last.

So it’s really like this:

2 choices for first position, then 1 choice for last position.

Then you fill in the middle positions (as you did correctly): 3 choices, 2 choices, one choice.

2 × 3 × 2 × 1 × 1 = 12

Oh. I thought it was her mom first and then dad last. I didn’t think about the second option. Do you have any more questions with probability? Also, I am a 7th grader and I just took my SAT on Jan 26. I received a 660 in math and a 1910 overall. However, I think a LOT of my mistakes in math are careless. I just did your diagnostic 1 and I got 17/20. 2 of them were careless; one was not.

It really can’t be this easy. I’ve watched so many videos on youtube about this and I’ve gotten so confused between combinations and permutations! Its so easy that I’m almost believe I’m being deceived.

I have a problem with a concept , when i think about for example what to put in the second spot I’m confused to think 1/6 or just 6 🙁 can you help clear that up? thanks!

sure, #20 “To fill Position 1, Mike has 6 different awards to choose from.” I’m confused about whether to write 6 or 1/6 because we need to choose one of the six awards.

Oh. Write 6—in a counting question like this, we’re trying to come up with the total number of ways something can be done. We want our answer to be a big number!

I think you’re getting confused because you’re thinking about this like it’s a probability question, but it’s not. And even if it were, for most probability questions you’re just going to do counting operations twice—once for the constrained number of favorable outcomes, and one for the total possible outcomes. So if 20 were a probability question, like it asked for the probability that the Math Award ended up in the middle if all the awards were placed randomly, then you’d do 6*5*4*1*3*2*1 for the favorable outcomes like above, and then do 7*6*5*4*3*2*1 for the total possible outcomes. You’d divide those and get 1/7 as the probability. 🙂

Oh okay, so I’ve been confused between Possibilities and Probabilities! Thanks for clearing that up ! 🙂 <3

Leave a Reply